Feeling Un-American

For a U.S. citizen there are few words more emotionally charged than un-American. It has been used to demean political opponents and discredit those who question authority. It will no doubt be directed at me following this publication, but lately I have been feeling a little un-American. (Notice the qualifier – I still have trouble saying it out loud.)

In my defense, I believe it is the country that has changed, not me. I feel the Trump administration and congressional leaders have drawn the nation away from traditional American values and it doesn’t feel like home these days.

We used to be a country in which anyone with a good idea who was willing to work hard could make it big, or at least end up better off than the prior generation. We were a leader in the fields of military power, human rights, global stewardship, humanitarian assistance and (sometimes) peaceful resolutions to regional conflicts. We took care of Americans who needed help getting by and protected those in the sunset years of their lives. The U.S. used to be a beacon of truth because freedom of the press generally kept government honest.

Most of that seems to have changed recently, although the military power part remains intact and the Chapter 11 bankruptcy laws encourage entrepreneurial endeavors. The rest, however, is in flux and it feels un-American.

The U.S. under the Trump administration is acting like a bully. Mr. Trump has decertified Iranian compliance with the nuclear deal even though Iran has followed the letter of the agreement. If Congress decides to implement new sanctions, most or all of the other countries which signed the deal would side with Iran. Senator Tom Cotton’s response is indicative of a bully mentality: “Do they want to deal with the United States’ $19 trillion economy, or do they want to deal with Iran’s economy … about the size of Maryland?”

The U.S. is also getting good at blaming the victim. President Trump’s tweets and speeches are full of examples which include blaming Iran for an ISIS attack in Tehran, blaming Puerto Rico for the hurricane damage it suffered, and blaming women in the military for the 26,000 unreported sexual assaults in 2014. And then there’s Charlottesville, although Mr. Trump is not alone there. Arizona Rep. Paul Gosar put forth a completely false claim that the rally was “created by the left” and carried out by an “Obama sympathizer.”

The big picture is disturbing. The Republican leaders in the federal government have worked hard to strip health insurance from tens of millions, cut social safety net programs, greatly reduce taxes on the wealthy and add to the federal deficit. They are intent on weakening environmental stewardship at home and around the world, they will make it more difficult for business upstarts to succeed by eliminating net neutrality and they will reduce access to birth control so there will be more unwanted pregnancies, but also restricted access to abortion and pre-natal care.

It is simply un-American.

This behavior is likely the result of too much power concentrated in one nation. The United States certainly has the world’s strongest military by far, but its economy is also a powerhouse. There’s an 80:20 rule in business – eighty percent of the sales come from twenty percent of the customers. In a healthy economic system, that should also apply to charitable donations, college financial aid packages, and gross domestic product (GDP) of countries. The world’s economies do not meet this rule. Twelve percent of the countries generate eighty percent of the GDP, and the United States accounts for twenty-five percent by itself.

And so, under our current leadership, that position of strength is viewed as a reason to force their agenda onto others – domestic and international. Past leaders viewed our place in the world a little differently. Our strength was both a virtue and a challenge. We recognized the benefits of being in a position to lead and that a stable world order would be good for both U.S. and other countries. We took that blessing and responsibility seriously.

America has become selfish and is rife with infighting. President Trump’s tweets fuel this divisiveness and the country is losing its identity. We have become a nation of us versus them, rather than one of unity. Past leaders have attempted to bridge the divide, but Mr. Trump thrives on sowing discontent; that is how he won the presidency after all.

My wife’s Canadian relatives always complained that the United States co-opted the term ‘American.’ Canada is in America too, as are all the other countries in North and South America. Canada is also a strong proponent of the freedoms that the United States has historically been known for. They take care of their people, offer a helping hand to those in real trouble, work hard for unity and strongly believe in the freedom of the press. No wonder Canadians would like to claim the ‘American’ title.

Perhaps I’m not feeling un-American lately; maybe I’m actually feeling Canadian. It’s all that CBC radio I used to listen to, I bet. (Rest in peace, Stuart McLean.)

About tonyj126

I'm a 50+ married man who always seems to have a large backlog of work to do, but also a lot of flexibility in my schedule. Much of the work I do is volunteer or taking care of extended family members. I suffer from, as my priest calls it, "the sin of self-sufficiency," which means I can figure out how to do most things myself, and consequently, reduce the need for community to solve problems. As a logical extention (at least to me), I find myself called to comtemplate the country's and the world's woes and offer my observations. I hope someone out there will find them useful.
This entry was posted in Economics, Make America Great Series, U.S. Politics, Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Feeling Un-American

  1. lly1205 says:

    Aside from the current government (where I think I agree with you), on the entrepreneurial side, I wonder if higher market concentration in recent years could be making it harder to compete and succeed. A strong incumbent discourages the entry of new competitors! But I’m no expert, and north of the border we have many highly concentrated markets… (*cough* telecom) Unrelated, I’ve never heard of Canadians wanting to co-opt the title of “American” before. Interesting


  2. tonyj126 says:

    Perhaps the Canadians wanting to co-opt the “American” title pre-dates you – that would have been 40-45 years ago for my wife. Alternatively, that came from first generation Polish-Candians and I’ve noticed that Poland’s history of sucesses and defeats is held close to the heart. There’s real pride in Madam Curie and the Polish generals who helped in the States’ War of Independence, Kosciuszko & Pulaski, but also some anguish that Poland is the European country that has been invaded more than any other (not sure it that’s true, but it’s stated by Polish-Americans/Canadians as truth). With that collective history, Polish-Canadians may have felt that U.S.’ exclusive use of “American” was unfair. Then again, my sample size is rather small – my wife’s cousins from decades ago.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s